A Letter Opposing AB 2446 and AB 35


Dear Senator Simitian,

I am writing to express my strong opposition to Assembly Bills 2446 and AB 35, both authored by Assemblyman Furutani. I appreciate your abstention on AB 2446 in the prior Committee vote, and urge you to take a stand and vote against both bills this time.

Here is why…

These bills should be dismissed based on one simple fact: Visual and Performing Arts, Foreign Language, and CTE are required courses of study in our state (California Education Code 51220). These subjects are deemed important enough to be required courses of study for all students; therefore, students should not be able to opt out of any of them.

Why do other required courses of study have stand alone requirements, while the Arts, Foreign Language, and CTE are expected to share one overcrowded line? Certainly the Committee can see the detrimental effect that this will have on all three subjects.

Consider this: Only 11% of California secondary schools are implementing the Visual and Performing Arts in accordance with the Education Code and Content Standards (Woodworth, et al., 2007). It’s not because they don’t want to, it’s because they can’t.

Wouldn’t it make more sense to enact legislation that would enable schools to implement the existing Education Code effectively, rather than continuing to undermine it?

AB 2446 and AB 35 are simply the wrong solution to a problem that has not been properly framed: namely, how can secondary schools provide access to high quality learning experiences that effectively prepare students for a variety of post-secondary options?

The problem is NOT that we technically can’t add more subsections to Education Code Section 51225, because we can. (I realize this has larger implications.)

The problem is NOT that students must choose between these three required courses of study, because they shouldn’t have to. (And I wonder, is that even legal?)

The problem IS that the school day and school year are too short and underfunded to provide the quality and scope of education we have already put into statute and that we know our students deserve.

We already know that without courses in both the Arts and Foreign Language, students will be ineligible to attend UC and CSU schools.

Why make this confusing for students and families? We know that our guidance system is weak. We know that some students will unwittingly opt out of college. Is the Legislature really willing to own that life-altering and expensive crack in the system?

We’re counting on you to find another solution, a better solution, hopefully the RIGHT solution. AB 2446 and AB 35 are not it.

Your very concerned constituent,
Dana Powell Russell, Ed.D.

2 Responses to “A Letter Opposing AB 2446 and AB 35”

  1. Briana Says:

    Hi, I agree with you. I am interested to read the Woodworth article that you cited. Will you please provide a full reference so I can find this article?


  2. Darren Willis Says:

    Presently 18 to 23 year-olds in Kern County have a 47 percent unemployment rate. What is wrong with students being able to take classes that prepare them for the world of work?

    One of the reasons that we have a 30%+ drop out rate in California is because students feel a disconnect between what they learn in school and what skills they will need to begin a career.

    I love for students to learn art and foreign language and feel that it is an important part of a well rounded education. However there comes a point that we have to make decisions about what is best for student’s future, not just our personal interests. Denying students the opportunity to take classes that teach skills that will help them begin careers is not the answer.

    California is moving in the direction of Career Technical Education. I would recommend we spend time and effort figuring out how you can fit into this paradigm instead of focusing on defeating legislation in order to limit student’s access to vocational training.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: